If you thought Scotland’s ‘hate speech’ law was bad, get a load of this. Justin Trudeau’s government in Canada has proposed its own hate speech legislation that could be applied to anything said or posted in the past, present or future.
Bill C-63, known as the Online Harms Act proposes potential prison sentences and huge fines for anyone who engages in wrongthink.
Now some are suggesting that the proposed legislation leaves the door open for it to be applied to past speech indiscretions.
It sounds so insane that Elon Musk asked Community Notes to fact check it, resulting in a clarification only that the legislation is not a law… yet.
Detractors argued that the proposed law doesn’t explicitly say it can be applied retroactively.
No it does not explicitly grant powers to law enforcement agencies to retroactively search the internet for 'hate speech' violations and arrest offenders for offenses committed before the law was enacted. Typically, laws in Canada cannot be applied retroactively to criminalize…
— Brian Krassenstein (@krassenstein) May 7, 2024
However, it doesn’t not say that either:
It's pretty close to accurate, Elon.
If someone has the ability to delete a "hate speech" tweet / post and does not, and someone else retweets that tweet, it would qualify as "publication" under the law and be sanctionable.
"For the purposes of subsection (1), a person commu-… pic.twitter.com/YK27N639Ap
— Viva Frei (@thevivafrei) May 7, 2024
In fact it specifically creates a so called ‘continuous communication’ clause that means old tweets, for example, that are still live can be considered current speech.
Bill C-63 would create a new section 13(2) of the Canadian Human Rights Act. It says you’re liable for anything you’ve ever posted (if you have the power to remove it now). Link here: https://t.co/nMZquwaZkB Screenshot below. pic.twitter.com/DMdJbWuzgm
— Ezra Levant